10 Best Butt Plugs in 2026

What separates this plug from the softer options on this list is the aluminum body with its ABS gem base: it holds temperature, has real heft, and comes in three sizes topping out at 3.7 inches long. It's rated 4.75 stars across 180 reviews, the best combination of rating and sample size here, and the hypoallergenic finish matters if cheaper metals have ever irritated your skin.

$7.50 makes this the cheapest metal plug in the roundup, and 391 reviews backing a 4.7-star rating make it one of the most trusted, too. It's a mix of aluminum, acrylic, and ABS with a faux gem base, hypoallergenic, and built for temperature play the same way the Red Hearts version above is.

Three glass plugs in graduated sizes make this the most straightforward training set here, rated 4.7 stars from 221 reviewers. Glass is genuinely nonporous, meaning it actually sterilizes between partners or uses rather than just claiming to, and like the metal plugs above, it holds heat or cold if you want to play with temperature.

Into roleplay more than a plain plug? This one pairs a silicone plug with a tapered tip to matching faux fur ears, rated 4.4 stars from 100 reviews with two styles available. Underneath the novelty, the plug itself is built the same safety-conscious way as any non-novelty option: tapered tip, narrow neck, flared base.

$4 and a 4.3-star rating from 410 reviewers make a hard combination to beat for a first purchase, and this is the cheapest plug in the entire category. It's soft TPR with a textured, bubbled 4-inch shaft, built specifically to be forgiving if you've never used a plug before.

This is the vibrating step up from the simple plugs above it, packing 10 modes into a rechargeable, waterproof silicone body. It's rated 4.2 stars across 296 reviews, a solid sample size, and the flared base and tapered tip still follow the same safety design as every non-vibrating pick on this list.

Not sure which texture you'll actually like? Four plugs, bubble, ribbed, smooth, and one more, for $11.50 is a reasonable way to find out. It's rated 4.1 stars from 191 reviews, and the TPE material is a step up in softness from the cheaper TPR options above.

This combines a penis ring with an anal plug on one silicone piece, a different category entirely from the standalone plugs above it, and it's the most-reviewed product on this list at 633 ratings. Its 4.0-star average holds up well at that volume, and the shape is designed to shift during movement rather than sit static.

$119 for only 14 reviews averaging 3.95 stars makes this the biggest bet on the list, but the Hush 2 is also the only app-controlled plug here, letting a partner control it remotely through Bluetooth from anywhere with a connection. It comes in four sizes, all rechargeable, waterproof silicone.

This is the only plug here with actual thrusting motion: 8 thrusting functions paired with 8 vibration patterns, a flexible stimulator aimed at the taint, and a wireless remote. It's rated 3.9 stars from 107 reviews, the lowest average on this list, which tracks, since mechanically complex toys tend to draw more mixed feedback than simple ones do.