10 Best Anal Toys in 2026

A 4.8-star rating from 56 reviewers makes this the highest-rated set in the whole category, and the three graduated acrylic sizes, 2.6 to 3.7 inches insertable, are exactly why I'd start someone here. The bodies are thicker than the tapered tips for a satisfying fill once they're in, and the gem-shaped bases carry actual glitter that catches light. At $22.50 for all three sizes, the per-plug cost is hard to beat.

$12.50 and 180 reviews at a 4.75-star average, a combination that's hard to find anywhere else on this list. This polished aluminum plug comes in three sizes (2.81, 3.25, and 3.73 inches long), so one listing covers beginners through experienced users, and the metal has real heft plus holds temperature well if you want to warm or cool it before use.

Want the most-reviewed anal toy on this entire list? This is it, at 391 reviews and a 4.7-star average, and it's also the cheapest entry point here at $7.50 for the small size. The aluminum plugs are sold by size (small, medium, large) with weight specs listed for each, from a light 1.8 ounces up to a hefty 5.7 ounces, so you know exactly what's showing up at your door.

Glass feels completely different from silicone or metal, and that's exactly why 221 reviewers rated this trio of plugs (4.5, 4.75, and 5.75 inches) at 4.7 stars. Because it's nonporous, you're free to use any lube with it, including silicone-based, which most of the metal and acrylic options on this list can't say. Chill or warm the glass in water first and the sensation changes completely.

152 reviews and a 4.7-star average puts this solidly in the upper half of the list. The three aluminum plugs run from 2.76 to 3.54 inches, each topped with a sparkly pink jewel base, and the polished metal is smooth enough that lube does most of the real work on insertion. At $22.50 for all three, it's priced right alongside our top pick.

Eighty-five reviewers landed this heart-themed trio at a 4.7-star average, and construction-wise it's nearly identical to the Pink Gem training set above (aluminum, three graduated sizes from 2.75 to 3.54 inches, flared bases). What sets it apart is presentation: heart-shaped jewels and an included velvet bag give it more of a special-occasion feel.

Why does this silicone training kit have nearly 1,200 reviews, more than every other anal toy in our top 10 combined? Suction-cup bases that stick to shower walls or chairs for hands-free play, three sizes running 4.5 to 6 inches, and a soft, flexible material that's gentler than metal or glass if you're just starting out.

This set is built for people who've already trained up, not beginners: the large plug reaches 8.25 inches insertable, well past anything else on this list. The TPE material is firm enough for penetration but flexible enough to move with the body, and all three pieces have suction-cup bases that double as harness compatibility.

13 reviews and a 4.55-star average is a small sample, but the early feedback on this rainbow chrome set is positive. Sizing runs from 1.75 to 2.98 inches insertable across the three pieces, with heart-shaped bases that double as the safety stop every plug needs.

Looking for the cheapest way in? At $9, this is the smallest and least expensive toy in our top 10, and 23 reviewers have kept it at a 4.5-star average. Instead of three separate sizes, it's a single graduated shaft with beads that widen from 1 to 1.5 inches as they go in, so the stimulation builds within one insertion rather than across a whole training set.